NEWJoin 2M+ software buyers|Get Weekly Insights, Trends & Expert PicksSubscribe free →

Spotsaas logo
Last updated:

6 Best Free ThePayStubs Alternatives in 2026

Explore 6 alternatives to ThePayStubs — vetted by our editors with real user reviews, pricing, and feature comparisons.

Top free ThePayStubs alternatives, compared at a glance

Quick answer

The ThePayStubs alternatives buyers shortlist most are Gusto, Freshbooks and Paycor. Gusto ranks first with a SpotScore of 9.7 and a 4.36★ rating. Compare all 6 on score, rating, and pricing below.

Choosing the right ThePayStubs alternative comes down to fit, and these 6 payroll software free alternatives cover a wide range of needs. We rank them by SpotScore, which blends verified satisfaction with market presence, then ratings and pricing. Each tool is editor-checked. Use the table to compare, then read each breakdown.

ProductSpotScoreRatingPricingBest for
GustoModern HR for Growing Businesses9.7★★★★☆ 4.36(947)Freefrom $49 /user/monthsmall & mid-size businesses
FreshbooksInvoicing made easy. Anytime, anywhere.9.6★★★★★ 4.59(1379)Freefrom $8/mosmall & mid-size businesses
PaycorTransform your workforce with Paycor.9.6★★★★☆ 3.74(552)FreeFree Trial · Quotation Basedteams of all sizes
SurePayrollEfficiency meets accuracy in one payroll solution.9.2★★★★★ 4.83(1436)FreeFree Trial · Quotation Basedteams of all sizes
Square PayrollStreamline your payroll with ease.8.8★★★★★ 5(15)Freefrom $34 /User/Monthteams of all sizes
InStaffStreamlining your workforce, simplified.7.9★★★★★ 4.6(2)FreeFree Trial · Subscriptionteams of all sizes

9.7

SpotScore

Gusto - Payroll Software

Gusto

Modern HR for Growing Businesses

Best for: SMB teams · Mid-market

Start Free Trial

4.4

947 verified reviews

Add to compare

watch-demo

Watch Demo

What is Gusto?

Gusto is a comprehensive HR platform designed to help businesses of all sizes thrive. Whether you’re just starting out or scaling rapidly, Gusto provides the tools and guidance you need to grow and nurture your team. Trusted by over 300,000 businesses across the U.S., Gusto combines payroll, ...

Read more about Gusto
Free TrialTry Free →·

Gusto offers custom pricing plan

9.6

SpotScore

Freshbooks

Freshbooks

RECOMMENDED

Invoicing made easy. Anytime, anywhere.

Best for: SMB teams · Mid-market

4.6

1379 verified reviews

Add to compare

What is Freshbooks?

FreshBooks is cloud accounting software for freelancers, small agencies, and service businesses with under 10 employees who handle their own books. It automates invoicing, expense categorization, and time-to-invoice workflows so owners can bill clients and track billable hours without a ...

Read more about Freshbooks
Free TrialTry Free →·

Freshbooks offers custom pricing plan

9.6

SpotScore

Paycor - HR Software

Paycor

RECOMMENDED

Transform your workforce with Paycor.

Best for: SMB teams · Mid-market · Enterprise

3.7

552 verified reviews

Add to compare

watch-demo

Watch Demo

What is Paycor?

Paycor is a human capital management platform for mid-size businesses and nonprofits that need payroll processing, time tracking, benefits administration, and employee onboarding managed in a single system. It eliminates the need for separate payroll and HR tools by centralizing people ...

Read more about Paycor
Free TrialTry Free →·

Paycor offers custom pricing plan

9.2

SpotScore

SurePayroll - Payroll Software

SurePayroll

Efficiency meets accuracy in one payroll solution.

Best for: SMB teams · Mid-market · Enterprise

Start Free Trial

4.8

1436 verified reviews

Add to compare

watch-demo

Watch Demo

What is SurePayroll?

SurePayroll is a cloud-based, Payroll Software with Time Tracking Service. The software can be accessed from any device and is hosted by SurePayroll in the Amazon Web Services (AWS) data center for fast processing and performance.It automates most employee related tasks including accurate and ...

Read more about SurePayroll
Free Trial·

SurePayroll offers custom pricing plan

Spotsaas Ads

Want your product up here? Put it in front of buyers the moment they're comparing your category.

Reach in-market buyersRank above rivals2M+ buyers a year
Advertise your product

8.8

SpotScore

Square Payroll - Payroll Software

Square Payroll

Streamline your payroll with ease.

Best for: SMB teams · Mid-market · Enterprise

Start Free Trial

5.0

15 verified reviews

Add to compare

What is Square Payroll?

Square Payroll is payroll software for small businesses and sole proprietors, particularly those already running payments or point-of-sale through Square's ecosystem. It automates pay runs, tax filings, and direct deposit, and pulls time tracking data directly from Square tools to eliminate ...

Read more about Square Payroll
Free TrialTry Free →

7.9

SpotScore

InStaff - HR Software

InStaff

Streamlining your workforce, simplified.

Best for: SMB teams · Mid-market · Enterprise

Start Free Trial

4.6

2 verified reviews

Add to compare

watch-demo

Watch Demo

What is InStaff?

InStaff is a cloud-based HR platform for small and mid-sized businesses that centralizes employee document management, time and attendance tracking, and internal communications in one place. It reduces reliance on paper-based processes by giving employees and managers a single online system for ...

Read more about InStaff
Free TrialTry Free →

Why these ThePayStubs alternatives stand out

Gusto9.7Best for small & mid-size businesses

Handles payroll processing and tax compliance without requiring accounting expertise.

Watch for: Occasional reports of errors in support communication or inconsistencies in handling complex account issues.

Freshbooks9.6Best for small & mid-size businesses

User-friendly interface, making it simple to set up and use even for non-accounting experts.

Watch for: Reporting functionalities and customizations are less capable compared to industry giants, limiting advanced financial analysis.

Paycor9.6Best for teams of all sizes

Covers payroll, recruiting, onboarding, performance management, and benefits administration in one platform.

Watch for: Customer service response times are consistently slow, with no assigned representatives and frequent case mismanagement.

SurePayroll9.2Best for teams of all sizes

Payroll setup is quick, easy to use, and simplifies previously cumbersome tasks like tax deductions and filings.

Watch for: Occasional issues with missing payments or discrepancies that require follow-up.

Square Payroll8.8Best for teams of all sizes

Square Payroll integrates effortlessly with existing payroll providers, making it an ideal plug-and-play solution without the need for major system overhauls.

Watch for: While great for small businesses, it may lack some of the advanced reporting, analytics, or customization features needed by larger enterprises.

InStaff7.9Best for teams of all sizes

InStaff enhances communication within organizations, helping teams stay connected and informed without relying on external communication tools.

Watch for: The platform’s simplicity may not be enough for larger organizations that require more advanced HR functionalities or detailed reporting.

Why teams look for a ThePayStubs alternative

There are a few common reasons buyers start shopping for a ThePayStubs alternative:

  • The platform is excellent for pay stub creation but lacks broader payroll management features like direct deposits or tax filings.
  • It doesn't integrate with external accounting or HR platforms, which may limit its utility for growing businesses.
  • While useful for occasional needs, regular users may find the per-stub pricing model costly over time.

What a good ThePayStubs alternative should have

Side by side, the 6 free alternatives break down like this: 6 offer a free tier; paid plans run $8–$49, with Freshbooks the cheapest entry point; and Square Payroll is the highest rated at 5★ across 15 reviews.

Our ranking criteria.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Stuck on something? We're here to help with all the questions and answers in one place.

The top-rated alternatives to ThePayStubs are Square Payroll (5.0★), SurePayroll (4.8★), InStaff (4.6★). Compare all 6 alternatives side-by-side above.

When evaluating alternatives to ThePayStubs, prioritize: Wage Garnishment, W-2 Preparation, Leave Tracking (Vacation), Self Service Portal, Direct Deposit, transparent pricing, free trial availability, and integrations with your existing tools. Use the filters above to compare by feature, budget, and team size.

Migration difficulty depends on how deeply ThePayStubs is integrated into your workflows. Most alternatives offer data export/import tools and dedicated onboarding support. We recommend shortlisting 2–3 options, running a free trial, and checking each vendor's migration guides before committing.

Which ThePayStubs alternative should make your shortlist?

  • On a budget / just exploring: start with a free tier — Gusto, Freshbooks and Paycor let you evaluate without paying upfront.
  • If real-user ratings matter most: Square Payroll has the strongest star rating (5★) among the options with verified reviews.
  • Want the safest pick: Gusto has the highest Spotsaas Score (9.7) in this list — a strong default if you're unsure.

How to leave ThePayStubs behind

Switching away from ThePayStubs is safest in stages. Export your data, verify the new tool can import it, and confirm the features you depend on. Run a pilot first, then migrate fully, keeping ThePayStubs running until you've validated the fit. Free trials above help.

Disclaimer: This research has been collated from a variety of authoritative sources. We welcome your feedback at [email protected].