spotsaas-logo
Get Listed

Square Payroll vs Gusto vs Payroller vs Paychex Flex - Which Tool Fits Your Business?

Get Quote
Gusto - Payroll Software
Get Quote
Get Quote
Payroller - Payroll Software
Get Quote
Get Quote

TL;DR - Quick Comparison Summary

Description

Square Payroll is our new, easy-to-use payroll software that integrates with your existing payroll provider. It helps you pay employees faster, keep better track of hours worked, and ... Read More

Gusto is a comprehensive HR platform designed to help businesses of all sizes thrive. Whether you’re just starting out or scaling rapidly, Gusto provides the tools and guidance you need to ... Read More

Payroll is easy with our powerful, yet simple-to-use desktop software. With options that help you manage taxes, reduce errors and cut labor costs, payroll can be an integral part of growing ... Read More

Entry Level Pricing

  • Starts from $34
  • Starts from $40 , monthly
  • Starts from $1.99

Free Trial Availability

  • No free trial

Spotsaas Score

8.8/10

9.7/10

8.1/10

User Ratings

Get Quote
Get Quote
Get Quote

Software Demo

Demo

Payroller has not given any software demo yet

If you're the owner of this profile, add your demo.Contact us

How do Square Payroll, Gusto, Payroller and Paychex Flex Compare on Features?

Total Features

13 Features

54 Features

4 Features

Unique Features

        Get Quote
        Get Quote
        Get Quote

        What Do Square Payroll, Gusto, Payroller and Paychex Flex Cost?

        Pricing Option

              Starting From

              • $34
              • $40 , monthly
              • $1.99

              Pricing Plans

              • Not Available
              • Simple

                $40

                /user/month

                • Full-service single-state payroll including W-2s and 1099s

                • Basic support

                • Employee profiles and self-service

                Show more +

              • Plus

                $60

                /user/month

                • Everything in the Simple plan, plus

                • Full-service multi-state payroll including W-2s and 1099s

                • Advanced hiring and onboarding tools

                Show more +

              • Premium

                $135

                /user/month

                • Dedicated Customer Success Manager

                • HR resource center

                • Compliance alerts

                Show more +

              • Not Available

              Pricing Page

              square-payroll pricinggusto pricingpayroller pricing

              Other Details

              Organization Types supported

              • Freelancers
              • Large Enterprises
              • Medium Business
              • Small Business
              • Individuals
              • Freelancers
              • Large Enterprises
              • Medium Business
              • Small Business
              • Individuals
              • Freelancers
              • Large Enterprises
              • Medium Business
              • Small Business
              • Individuals

              Platforms Supported

              • Browser Based (Cloud)
              • Mobile - Android
              • Mobile - iOS
              • Installed - Windows
              • Installed - Mac
              • Browser Based (Cloud)
              • Browser Based (Cloud)
              • Mobile - Android
              • Mobile - iOS
              • Installed - Windows
              • Installed - Mac
              • Browser Based (Cloud)
              • Browser Based (Cloud)
              • Mobile - Android
              • Mobile - iOS
              • Installed - Windows
              • Installed - Mac
              • Browser Based (Cloud)

              Modes of support

              • 24/7 (Live rep)
              • Business Hours
              • Online
              • 24/7 (Live rep)
              • Business Hours
              • Online
              • 24/7 (Live rep)
              • Business Hours
              • Online

              API Support

              • Available
              • Available
              • Not Available
              Get Quote
              Get Quote
              Get Quote

              Square Payroll vs Gusto vs Payroller User Reviews & Rating Comparison

              User Ratings

              3.9

              (based on 586 reviews)

              No reviews available for the product

              Rating Distribution

              Excellent

              0

              Very Good

              0

              Good

              0

              Poor

              0

              Terible

              0

              Excellent

              677

              Very Good

              36

              Good

              12

              Poor

              15

              Terible

              117

              No reviews available for the product

              Expert's Review generated by AI

              Square Payroll delivers a clean, efficient, and straightforward solution for small to medium-sized businesses looking to streamline payroll operations. I was especially impressed by how easily it ...Read more

              Gusto has earned widespread praise as an intuitive, reliable, and user-friendly payroll and HR management platform. Its seamless setup process, affordability, and robust features, such as payroll ...Read more

              Payroller offers a practical and straightforward desktop payroll solution designed to meet the core needs of small to mid-sized businesses. I found its simplicity refreshing, with features like ...Read more

              Pros and Cons

              Pros and Cons of Square Payroll

              • Square Payroll integrates effortlessly with existing payroll providers, making it an ideal plug-and-play solution without the need for major system overhauls.

              • Its simple and intuitive design makes payroll management easy even for business owners or HR teams with limited technical expertise.

              • Built-in time tracking allows accurate logging of hours worked, which improves payroll precision and reduces manual errors.

              • The platform accelerates employee payments, helping businesses meet payment deadlines and improve worker satisfaction.

              • While great for small businesses, it may lack some of the advanced reporting, analytics, or customization features needed by larger enterprises.

              • Full functionality may be best realized when used within the broader Square ecosystem, limiting flexibility for companies using other systems.

              Pros and Cons of Gusto

              • Simplifies payroll processing and tax compliance, making it user-friendly even for non-experts.

              • Offers robust integrations with platforms like QuickBooks Online and other accounting systems.

              • Excellent customer support that is responsive, timely, and efficient in resolving issues.

              • Comprehensive features for businesses, including onboarding, benefits management, retirement plans, and compliance support.

              • Occasional reports of errors in support communication or inconsistencies in handling complex account issues.

              • Some users find the transition from alternative payroll providers to Gusto challenging without adequate guidance.

              Pros and Cons of Payroller

              • The software offers a simple, desktop-based interface that caters to businesses looking for a straightforward payroll solution without cloud complexities.

              • With support for importing employee data and using pre-printed checks, it significantly reduces the time spent on manual data entry.

              • Built-in mechanisms to reduce errors make payroll processing more reliable and less prone to costly mistakes.

              • The platform helps manage taxes effectively, which is essential for compliance and accurate payroll reporting.

              • Lack of integration with accounting, HR, or time-tracking software could hinder full automation and increase administrative overhead.

              • Being restricted to desktop use may limit accessibility for remote teams or multi-location operations that rely on cloud-based access.

              Positive Reviews

              No reviews available for the product

              No reviews available for the product

              No reviews available for the product

              List of Customers

              Customers

              No Customers information available.

              Handlebar Cyclery

              Handlebar Cyclery

              Dwg

              Dwg

              American Canning

              American Canning

              No Customers information available.

              Media and Screenshots

              Screenshots

              Capterra : Square Payroll screenshot

              6 Screenshots

              gusto

              4 Screenshots

              Payroller screenshot

              5 Screenshots

              Videos

              video-0

              1 Videos

              video-0

              1 Videos

              No videos available.

              Add to Compare

              Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

              Stuck on something? We're here to help with all the questions and answers in one place.

              Yes, both Square Payroll and Gusto offer a Free Trial.

              Square Payroll is designed for Large Enterprises, Medium Business and Small Business.

              Gusto is designed for Freelancers, Medium Business and Small Business.

              Pricing for Square Payroll Starts at $34/User/Month whereas for Gusto Starts at $40/user/month when monthly.

              Some top alternatives to Square Payroll includes Paychex Flex, Freshbooks, PaymentEvolution, Gusto, Paycom, RUN Powered by ADP, QuickBooks Payroll, Paybooks, Papaya Global, Multiplier, ADP Payroll Services, Coverio, Paycor, NETCHEX and Quikchex.

              Some top alternatives to Gusto includes Paychex Flex, Freshbooks, BambooHR, Rippling, ADP Workforce Now, Justworks, Zenefits, Paycom, OnPay, RUN Powered by ADP, QuickBooks Payroll, Deel, Remote.com, Papaya Global, Multiplier, ADP Payroll Services, Remofirst, Paycor, NETCHEX and Elite HRMS.

              Disclaimer: This research has been collated from a variety of authoritative sources. We welcome your feedback at [email protected].

              Connecting Smart Buyers with Leading Sellers

              Find the perfect software for your needs or showcase your product to 250,000+ buyers. SpotSaaS makes it easy for everyone to succeed