SurePayroll Reviews in August 2026: User Ratings, Pros & Cons

Good Service, Support. Great Value

We needed to get our small company on a payroll system since we knew nothing about payroll and paying the govt properly. We researched and spoke with four providers and went with SurePayroll. The interface was easy to follow and intuitive, we did not wish to become payroll software experts. Our rep Chris Martin is good to work with, approachable and helpful while we asked plenty of questions before and after signing up. turns out SurePayroll has an integration into our accounting system so ...

Jarett Pesci and SurePayroll are truly an asset to our business

In recently taking over the payroll for the company, we went from in-house for our small family run business to choosing SurePayroll. From our first phone call with Jarett Pesci, we have been guided through the process in the most professional manner we could ever hope for. All of our anxieties and fears from taking this huge step into the unknown were handled by a very patient Jarett. He has been so kind, thoughtful, proactive, knowledgeable and responsive in every step of the way. Every ...

Quin was great

Quin was great, just looking for some help with payroll, but he went above and beyond, helping with W2s, that I did not call about. He was a big help.

Jarrett Pesci represents SurePayroll is…

Jarrett Pesci represents SurePayroll is a friendly, professional way. Mr. Pencil made signing up easy, and worked with me every step of the way.

Jarret Pesci made sure my first payroll…

Jarret Pesci made sure my first payroll ran smoothly and helped me make sure my account was set up correctly.

I thought the sign-up process was good

I thought the sign-up process was quite easy and streamlined. My rep was cautious and asked me to check a few things first when the initial ID's I gave her were questionable. She had good follow-ip fit me into her schedule to resolve issues and get me on track.

Heidi was very patient with me as she…

Heidi was very patient with me as she walked me through the process. Super easy to navigate.

Jarrett Pesci 5 star treatment from start to finish!

Jarrett Pesci stayed on top of my enrollment process and made the entire process from start to finish an ease. I would highly recommend this service to other business owners as well. In fact, I have already referred a business owner I know personally. Thanks for all your help Jarrett!

Great Experience

Aaron Rhodes was great to work with. He took the time to answer all my questions and walked me through the first payroll- it was way easier than I thought it would be! I definitely recommend this company and especially Aaron. Thanks!

I just talked to the nicest most…

I just talked to the nicest most helpful person. Pam Waters is a shear joy to work with. She was caring, helpful and kind. I have had a horrible week and from the way she treated me and my staff it turned everything around. When people know their job and speak to you with respect it can change a day. She made us joyful. Thank you Pam!