SurePayroll Reviews in August 2026: User Ratings, Pros & Cons

Flawless

What do you like best? It's so easy to use. I like the interface but mostly the ease of use and their ability to pay my withholding on time What do you dislike? The price is too high. I'm the only one using the service and it's really expensive. Recommendations to others considering the product Do it. What business problems are you solving with the product? What benefits have you realized? They file my withholding taxes.

sure payroll

What do you like best? Easy use and quick response with customer service. There on-line help desk is outstanding. What do you dislike? So far I have no complaints with Sure Payroll Recommendations to others considering the product It is economical and efficient. What business problems are you solving with the product? What benefits have you realized? They process all required documentation for Fed and State leaving me time to do other things. Also, if there is an issue all I have ...

Surepayroll Recommendation

What do you like best? Surepayroll has been user friendly for the past 12 years that I've used it, and always improving! When I've needed assistance, it's been there and it has always been very helpful. I am most pleased with the tax reporting and W-2, W-3 and 941 accuracy. I used to this by hand and it's a pleasure to have this done by SurePayroll and not have to worry that there will be mistakes (there never have been. And, the price is right!! What do you dislike? I don't actually ...

Best simple payroll service

What do you like best? With Surepay you can get your payroll done fast, online and easy. What do you dislike? Base charge for missed pay period if check date lands outside of month What business problems are you solving with the product? What benefits have you realized? The time that is saved from quickly entering payroll info online. Not worrying about tax filings, deduction, or withholding is worth allot more then Surepay charges. Additional the benefit of having my workers comp ...

Gets the job done, but feels a bit dated

What do you like best? We've been able to use SurePayroll for many years now, and it's always gotten the job done. Most useful has been their help in filing most necessary state and federal tax forms. The reporting is pretty useful, and the Customer Service is responsive. What do you dislike? The whole experience feels a bit dated compared to something like ZenPayroll, especially from the employee's perspective. We've thought about moving to something else, but I can't imagine trying ...

Surepayroll the best system around for a small business

What do you like best? Online capabilities, low fees and ease of use. What do you dislike? Cannot do bulk changes for groups of employee and not compatible with Zenefits. Recommendations to others considering the product Great for small business What business problems are you solving with the product? What benefits have you realized? Solving payroll issues and tax payments

Simple, Easy, Efficient Payroll System

What do you like best? I have used many payroll systems in the past (ADP, TriNet, Paychex, Ceridian, others and SurePayroll is super easy to navigate, has an intuitive GUI and offers simplicity of reporting. Whether adding employees, processing payroll, looking up information on terminated employees, reviewing the reports for the previous pay cycle or adding a one-time extra pay or deduction on an individual basis, SurePayroll is easy and efficient. What do you dislike? Not much. Maybe ...

Why not get the best.

What do you like best? It is an easy painless way to take care of my payroll. I have never been disappointed with the help that was available when I needed it. The direct deposit option is highly recommended. What do you dislike? I have no dislikes. I spend so much less time on payroll with SurePayroll Recommendations to others considering the product you have nothing to loose by trying it out. With every new system there is a learning curve. Once learned it gets pretty easy. What ...

Terrific solution for our payroll administration.

What do you like best? Dependability- I can process payroll at any time and have the flexibility to do so remotely and in advance when I am traveling. What do you dislike? I am unable to designate entries for employer-paid health insurance premiums and company car allowances that can be listed on year-end w-2 forms. Current California State requirements for providing, tracking and reporting mandatory minimum sick leave accruals need to be addressed by SurePayroll software solutions ...

Excellent Program and Easy

What do you like best? SurePayroll makes payroll day an easy day, not the dreaded one as before. Fast, easy, reliable. The fact that they take care of all of the reports without me having to worry about it makes them priceless. What do you dislike? I can't think of anything I dislike about this program. Recommendations to others considering the product I used to dread payroll, now I look forward to it, getting it done in seconds. I know the reports are accurate and done on time. No ...