SurePayroll Reviews in August 2026: User Ratings, Pros & Cons

I have used surepayroll to run my payroll for almost decade - no complaints.

What do you like best? Easy to use site. Reasonable cost and great customer service. What do you dislike? Sometimes I don't need the reminder to run payroll - I choose to skip it for a month or two. Recommendations to others considering the product It will make running your business easier - don't have to think about payroll/ What business problems are you solving with the product? What benefits have you realized? I don't have to specialize in running payroll - I can focus on ...

Happy customer for 5+ years!

What do you like best? Running payroll is a stressful and time-consuming process, but SurePayroll makes it as easy as possible. Inputting employees hours, vacation time, and bonuses is very straightforward (couldn't be simpler, really. Direct deposit is a breeze to set-up (less than a minute per employee, and in over 5 years of using SurePayroll I haven't had a single issue with anything payroll tax related - they handle it entirely and they handle it very well. When I do run into a snag, ...

I have used SurePayroll for over 10 years and we have been very satisfied.

What do you like best? Surepayroll is very easy to use and helps me complete payroll in just a few minutes. What do you dislike? I wish the benefits reports function would allow me to delete old employees. What business problems are you solving with the product? What benefits have you realized? Timely tax filings are very beneficial

SurePayroll makes payroll fast and easy

What do you like best? Handling payroll takes just a couple minutes and a few clicks. Employees like the direct deposit. I like the fact SurePayroll files our quarterly reports and completes our W-2 forms. What do you dislike? Cannot think of anything I dislike at this time. What business problems are you solving with the product? What benefits have you realized? More secure payroll processing compared to internal users in small company. Can be done from anywhere. Saves time and hassle.

Seamless and flawless.

What do you like best? What I like best is that it takes me only very minimal effort to perform Payroll duties in my dental office employing 7 team members. I receive email updates every pay period giving me my due date for submitting. Team members supply me with their data, I enter it, and it takes me 10 minutes at most to complete a task that used to be a very detailed, long and hated task. The subsequent payroll reports are easily accessed and easy to read. I then enter those reports ...

A Company on Which to Rely

What do you like best? SurePayroll makes it easy and affordable to process payroll. When things change or the inevitable issue arises, their people are accessible, knowledgeable and able to get the work done expediently. What do you dislike? Increasing cost of service from SurePayroll given that I am one person. What business problems are you solving with the product? What benefits have you realized? Hope to add staff soon.

Best payroll vendor i've had.

What do you like best? There customer communication cannot be beat. What do you dislike? There isn't much to dislike. I've never had any problems with SurePayroll. Recommendations to others considering the product If your a small company, need online access for you and your employees as-well-aa customer care, this is the best payroll company I have found thus far. What business problems are you solving with the product? What benefits have you realized? As a small company, I ...

Great for small business

What do you like best? Simple, clear, easy to use. We are a home business with few employees and no great understanding of withholding, unemployment taxes, etc. Great to have a service that does it all at a reasonable cost. What do you dislike? Since we are a home business, we do not depend entirely on our income from it. Which means occasionally I forget to do a payroll. I wish that SurePayroll would not charge me a service fee on those occasions when I do not run a payroll... But as ...

The best and most user friendly online payroll service

What do you like best? It is very user friendly and the new website is even easier to nagivate What do you dislike? No complaints here. I've been very satisfied with the product. Recommendations to others considering the product Yes very easy to set up and use, especially if you know what you are doing What business problems are you solving with the product? What benefits have you realized? None

We Think SurePayroll is Great!

What do you like best? We are definitely a small business and I remember when I worked for another small business my boss would do the payroll each week, by hand, by himself. Now that I am on the other side of the picture I could NOT imagine doing the payroll myself each week. Thank goodness for SurePayroll. Whenever I have a question and need something explained the customer service reps are great. And patient with me: What do you dislike? There isn't really anything I dislike. The ...