MakeShift Reviews in June 2026: User Ratings, Pros & Cons

"Better Options Out There"

What do you like best about MakeShift? The most helpful part is that it integrates with ADP. What do you dislike about MakeShift? Makeshift is not great for healthcare staffing. There are so many other options that do staffing much more efficiently. It's unfortunate that you can't put in a fake employee or temp employee if you have agency staffing scheduled. Other staff then think the shifts aren't covered so they are more likely to not call in. This has been one of the biggest barriers to ...

"Overall easy to use, would love more personalization"

What do you like best about MakeShift? How easy it is to drag and drop shifts when creating a schedule or making edits What do you dislike about MakeShift? That Bereavement is the immediate first option when booking time off, staff do not know what bereavement is. It should be automatically "Designated Day Off". I also dislike that it lists each employee that has viewable access to a specific department. would be nice to let people view it without making the list of people for that schedule ...

"Leaves something to be desired"

What do you like best about MakeShift? I like the ability to save rotations to be used as an employee's typical schedule, and the ability to save shifts to be easily added into the calendar as well. It's easy to use. What do you dislike about MakeShift? I dislike that there's no way to print off an easily-read calendar for staff. I also don't have access to admin tools from the app. I would like to see a way to integrate the schedule with existing calendars, or to be able to print a nice ...

"It's easy to navigate through, it wasn't hard to learn how to use it."

What do you like best about MakeShift? The reminders for keeping within our alloted hours. What do you dislike about MakeShift? There really isn't anything, it's easy to use. What problems is MakeShift solving and how is that benefiting you? Creating a schedule easily

"Very easy to use."

What do you like best about MakeShift? Repeating weeks makes it quick and easy to use. What do you dislike about MakeShift? Can't think of anything that can be improved upon What problems is MakeShift solving and how is that benefiting you? Helping us accurately schedule our workforce week after week.

"It is easy to make the schedule and view the schedule, but I do not like ADP involvement"

What do you like best about MakeShift? Schedule Making Alerts me when team members clock in early or clock out late What do you dislike about MakeShift? ADP PTO not showing up on timesheets Switching shifts never works properly Time off requests should be able to be made directly through makeshift instead of ADP What problems is MakeShift solving and how is that benefiting you? None that I know of

"Really great scheduler!"

What do you like best about MakeShift? I love the swap shift function, it's very easy to coordinate changing shifts. What do you dislike about MakeShift? It would be great to add to my iPhones calendar What problems is MakeShift solving and how is that benefiting you? It allows less work for schedule as staff can work and swap shifts, and then schedule approves it.

"Used for work scheduling and communication"

What do you like best about MakeShift? It's live scheduling that is up to the minute with all team members. I personally like the Makeshift Connect as well. What do you dislike about MakeShift? My only suggestion would be to make Makeshift Connect more editable. Being able to delete group messages, adding people, etc. What problems is MakeShift solving and how is that benefiting you? It makes my scheduling easy. I love how it is up to the second and in this type of world today, it meshes ...

"Great customer service, additional features would make it better!"

What do you like best about MakeShift? Creating payroll spreadsheets and monitoring time clock punches is easy on MakeShift. The ability for staff to set and keep their availability updated is useful. What do you dislike about MakeShift? Department schedules cannot be layered on top of each other on different tabs. Switching between departments while scheduling can be cumbersome. Also, having a search bar when assigning employees through the available shift tab or positions tab would be ...

"MakeShift makes organizing my department a breeze"

What do you like best about MakeShift? The ease of adjusting my employee's schedules What do you dislike about MakeShift? Having to input each employee's shifts individually, as my staff work irregular hours I cannot see how this could be made any easier What problems is MakeShift solving and how is that benefiting you? Easy interpretation of varying shifts for all my employees Immediate access for my staff to view all changes to their shifts No