Cisco Umbrella vs Fortinet FortiProxy vs Barracuda Web Security and Filtering - Which Tool Fits Your Business?

Pros and Cons of Cisco Umbrella

• Cisco Umbrella combines DNS-layer protection, secure web gateway, CASB, and firewall capabilities into a unified platform, eliminating the need for multiple disparate tools.

• Backed by Cisco Talos, it leverages one of the world’s largest cyber intelligence databases, ensuring rapid and precise detection of evolving threats.

• Whether augmenting existing infrastructure or migrating to a full SASE architecture, Umbrella’s scalability makes it adaptable for enterprises of all sizes and cloud maturity levels.

• Repeatedly ranked #1 for security efficacy by AV-TEST, providing assurance of its reliability against malware, phishing, and data loss.

• Its robust feature set and Cisco branding come with a premium price, potentially limiting accessibility for smaller organizations or startups.

• Organizations not already in the Cisco ecosystem may experience a steeper learning curve when integrating with existing tools and workflows.

Pros and Cons of Fortinet FortiProxy

Pros and Cons of Barracuda Web Security and Filtering

• Available as both hardware and virtual appliance, offering deployment flexibility.

• Enables inspection of encrypted traffic for complete security coverage.

• Includes unlimited remote user licenses to protect users outside the corporate network.

• Powerful policy engine allows control over content access, bandwidth usage, and social media regulations.

• s: Comprehensive features and licensing might be expensive for small businesses.

• Real-time alerts and notifications are not clearly described, which may impact timely incident response.